Skip to Main Content
Submit your project or idea
Co-create with community
20 votes
Refine your idea
Submit your final proposal
Jury review (pending)
Thanks for your vote
This voting milestone has now ended, and the idea has progressed to a private milestone
Return to idea list
Thanks for approving the idea
This milestone has now ended, and the idea has progressed to a private milestone
Return to idea list

TV White Spaces

TV White Space aka “Super WiFi” refers to the unused TV channels in any given area. With AdNotes led TV White Spaces deployment, these vacant channels can be converted into wireless broadband internet. This innovative Technology has the ability to connect our worlds’s unconnected people.

Define three specific objectives that you would like to achieve with your proposal.

Provide wireless broadband access to hard to reach rural and marginalized communities in need of connectivity during the current and post Covid-19 pandemic through the quick deployment of Television White Spaces (TVWS) based hybrid wireless telecommunications networks.

Expand TVWS based hybrid networks across Sub-Sahara Africa by integrating value added services that target the rural and peri-urban under serviced market looking for affordable telecommunications access

Provide expansion and handling capability of local cellular mobile systems to accommodate sudden increases in local and outbound traffic through data offloading and wireless back-haul.

What problems (particularly in value chain competitiveness and global disruption) are your community’s stakeholders facing due to the Covid-19 pandemic?

Statistics South Africa research revealed in its annual General Household Survey that close to 90% of South African households do not have access to a fixed broadband Internet connection at home, meaning that broadband penetration in township and rural areas is close to zero. This is the case in the whole of Sub-Sahara Africa our area of interest. 

Despite almost ubiquitous coverage, rural cellular networks are still just too expensive for people to use so they resort to call back tactics and avoid making costly calls with no option to use data services as those are also expensive. 

The TVWS hybrid network provides a unique selling opportunity that will deliver affordable mobile broadband access to these rural consumers that otherwise present low average revenue per user (ARPU) that operators are least interested in. Thus the growth potential of the TVWS Hybrid technology mix will likely exceed these targeted niche boundaries, especially when we cover the greater target area and expand regionally.

At the moment as all daily activities migrate to digital platforms like working from home programs and online education, all these movements further exclude people from under serviced communities meaning Covid-19 epidemic is widening the current inequality gap in the Sub-Sahara Africa.

What minimum viable solution(s) are you proposing to address the challenge(s) in your community?

The concept of anywhere, anytime working learning has gained traction in recent years, AdNotes’ Television White Spaces (TVWS) technology has made this more possible and practical than ever before by promising to empower every rural based families, student and teacher in South Africa to finally participate meaningfully in this critical endeavor.

AdNotes' TVWS offering is not a standalone, silver bullet solution to all connectivity problems but is rather offered to the education centres and homes for an example as an efficiently packaged  hybrid wireless telecommunications solution in order to take advantage of and easily integrate with existing solutions such as fiber (e.g. BBI, Openserve) and satellite broadband (e.g. Yahsat), unlicensed (e.g. 5 GHz) and other licensed fixed wireless solutions (e.g. cellular mobile broadband). This serves to minimize the platform risk and helps to keep the cost down while extending their coverage to areas that those technologies could not reach on their own.

Despite almost ubiquitous coverage in urban areas, most broadband technologies such as mobile broadband and fibre, are still not sufficiently available in deep rural and ultra rural areas of South Africa that the country may wish to cover due to various technological and economic challenges.

The AdNotes TVWS hybrid solution on the other hand provides Superior Range, Coverage and Greater Signal Penetration than any existing broadband technologies on offer at the moment. Their frequencies can travel up to 25km away, penetrating foliage, stone, brick and even metal to penetrate and cover the treacherous and challenging, mountainous terrain presented by the South African rural areas, to cover about two to six times that of the current Wi-Fi technologies.

Share your story (your narrative)

This is not only an idea that exists today, but it is a reflection of the future that Nathi Mbele wishes to see unfold across Africa. 
 

It starts off with the story about Mandy Zulu, a pretty 16 year old girl from Harding outside of Port Shepstone in South Africa and her mother who is working as an Administrator for a Port Shepstone based XY Company. It finishes with you helping the Zulu family get a fixed broadband internet connection at their rural based home.

 
The story of Mandy begins with the fact that she walks 5 kilometres to school every day. Just like her single mother when going to work, Mandy also travels to Port Shepstone by connecting three different public transports to access the internet the internet cafe for one hour at $2 to do research for her school assignments during weekends. Mandy's mother spends 3 hours daily commuting to work with the public transport and she does not get an opportunity to up-skill herself or look for other work opportunities. Using the mobile internet for Mandy's school research and supporting her mother's work or study is not an option as this option is too expensive, it is equivalent to 15% of the Zulu family total monthly budget. We have all heard this story before, but do we really understand it? Many don’t understand it the first hundred times they hear it.  
 
A devastating social digital divide has become manifest during the COVID pandemic, we now all fully understand the Zulu family story. Barring an intervention, this divide will hold back millions of Africans from participating effectively in modern society just like Mandy and her mother. The access expansion offered by the TV White Spaces will transform the lives of marginalised South Africans by giving them access to learning, information and services. Combining mass affordable broadband access  will enable millions of low-income Africans to earn incomes in the local and global digital economy. Access-enabled learn from home and work from home will for an increasing number of citizens remove the apartheid or colony tax of long daily commutes.
 
The TV White Spaces create mass affordable, high-quality, uncapped broadband access to 6 million households directly and another 8 million households within walking distance, within three years. This will enable over 10 million South Africans like Mandy and her mother to work from home and to learn from home. The infrastructure roll-out itself will create over 36 000 jobs. Broadband access for individuals delivered quickly and affordably is critical during the COVID pandemic and its aftermath to enable the marginalised to protect their health, complete their education, build new skills, and access incomes.

Please provide any additional relevant information that you would like to share.

Nathi Mbele is 34 years old Telecoms Entrepreneur, Executive Chairman at AdNotes Digital & Chief Executive of AdNotes. Nathi is a member of the Global Shapers Community, one of the vibrant communities of the World Economic Forum. Through the World Economic Forum, Nathi has been actively involved with the South Africa Internet for All project led by the Department of Telecommunications and Digital Technologies since 2017. Nathi made a commitment to treat the internet as a public utility to be accessed by all citizens irrespective of geographic location, race, and social income.

AdNotes is a fully registered youth owned rural based company which has been newly licensed by the Independent Communications Authority of South Africa (ICASA) to operate and provide Internet services. We are members of the Internet Service Provider Association (ISPA) and the Wireless Access Providers' Association (WAPA) and uphold the ISPA Code of Conduct.

Your Final Proposal for challenge

yes

edited on Aug 31, 2020 by Nathi Mbele
Public (22)
You will need to login to post a comment
Alex Carle Jun 15, 2020

HI. I like the idea but it is not clear how this actually works. DO you need to invest in infrastructure. licencing, do people need a TV? can it work on phones as well as computers? etc. questions people like myself who are nto specialists in the area would ask. The viability of the tech and how it is different to other things in this space or options to address the digital devide.
thanks and good luck

Nathi Mbele Jun 16, 2020

Hello Alex. Thanks for the feedback. In responding to your questions I have attached a picture of a typical rural broadband network infrastructure that we need to invest on before we can provide broadband internet services in rural areas. However, this is a very affordable telecommunications infrastructure, easy to deploy and maintain as well. In terms of how does it work; we install a radio with an antenna at your house / business - run a cable to your router, a database reports a list of vacant channels that won't cause interference to link with, then the base station sends a signal back to your house / business' antenna confirming the connection. Your router will distribute internet through wi-fi inside your house. It is different because an antenna at your house does not need line of sight to the base station, cost benefits and it uses the same frequencies that broadcasters use to get programming to our TV/FM Radio. TVWS signal is very strong in rural areas this is a better affordable option to address the digital divide.

Users tagged:

Sunday Bawa Jun 15, 2020

Sounds quite like a great opportunity but aren't this unused channels and unused frequencies under some government control? Any safety concerns ? For the rural areas are you going to provide low cost televisions with inbuilt customed antennas ?

Nathi Mbele Jun 16, 2020

Hello Sunday. Thanks for your questions. Indeed those unused channels are under local regulator's custodianship now for the fact that such channels are vacant that means spectrum is wasted. Most governments in Africa have realized that problem and they've started to give us permission to use those channels for this purpose and in South Africa our local regular has issued guidelines seeking to migrate all other used channels meaning issues of possible interference within those low bands will be minimal. In rural areas we will be mess networks to enable the community to get internet access through wi-fi using their mobile phones, laptop or any devices with wi-fi capabilities.

Users tagged:

Sunday Bawa Jun 16, 2020

Okay. Understood. And am sorry I have run out of votes I was only allocated 12 votes. Best wishes

Nathi Mbele Jun 16, 2020

I totally understand thank you for future support.

Nivashini Rave Rattey Jun 16, 2020

Hi Nathi Mbele,
Thank you for sharing the overview of your idea- it seems like a good opportunity to solve problems with internet connections. However, can you please elaborate more on the viability of this project? What have you done so far and what must be done? What is your ask?

Your story needs some work. Please read our storytelling factsheet to know how.

Users tagged:

Nathi Mbele Jun 16, 2020

Hi Nivashini. Thanks for checking us out and asking questions. Through various pilots conducted so far this project is certainly viable. TV White Space allows us to reach into rural areas where there’s no connectivity and open new markets for local communities, small businesses, rural farmers and improves government service delivery. It has given is hope for more digital solutions within the following sectors; forest, border, coast guard, police patrol, fishing, disaster evaluation, to name a few. We have secured tv white space operator's licenses, secured land to build TVWS towers and base stations to service about 1 million people, we have done a full network deployment plan, assembled and trained local team members. We just need to order approved radios and required infrastructure to build the whole network. We are reaching out to impact investors or agencies willing to join hands with us as we connect our world's unconnected people. This will be our last step before putting our foot into the market.

Users tagged:

Alex Carle Jun 16, 2020

Very interesting. Thank you for explaining. Best of luck. Sorry but i have run out of votes!

Nathi Mbele Jun 16, 2020

Much appreciated the journey is still very long ahead, you might one of our customers :)

Israel Abazie Jun 23, 2020

Your explanation is well detailed.

It's evident you have made thorough research and are designing the product to be deployed to market with users in mind. However, you will need to tell us if there is a limit on devices connected to your TVWS. Can too many devices slow it down? Keep going. You are almost there. Well done!

Nathi Mbele Jun 28, 2020

Thanks for such encouraging comments. The majority of the network will be deployed using a mesh topology multiple connections mean (in theory) that no node should be isolated. The multiple connections mean each node can transmit to and receive from more than one node at the same time. The best advantage is even more new nodes can be added without interruption or interfering with other nodes to avoid slowing it down when more devices are added.

Users tagged:

Tafadzwa Chikwereti Jul 4, 2020

Have you carried out your test pilot ?

Nathi Mbele Jul 5, 2020

We conducted a joint pilot project in South Africa with several stakeholders. Approved TVWS EOMs have done and completed further tests in SA, Nigeria, Namibia, Kenya & soon in Tanzania we are monitoring EOMs developments in these countries since we are aiming to participate in these markets as well.

Users tagged:

Jude Okoye Jul 6, 2020

We will be looking forward to using your Internet solution as our service rely on internet service for optimal service delivery

Nathi Mbele Jul 28, 2020

Thank you for the support Jude. Where are you from? We are certainly looking for other market in within the Sub-Saharan region in Africa.

Users tagged:

Jude Okoye Jul 28, 2020

I am from Nigeria. If your internet solution can achieve at least 3MBPS , we will recommend it to our clients.

Nivashini Rave Rattey Jul 8, 2020

The idea has been progressed to the next milestone.

Nathi Mbele Jul 28, 2020

Looking forward to redefine the idea :)

Users tagged:

Nivashini Rave Rattey Jul 8, 2020

Status labels added: Community feedback received, Expert feedback received

Nathi Mbele Jul 28, 2020

Much appreciated

Users tagged:

Nivashini Rave Rattey Jul 9, 2020

Status label removed: Expert feedback received

James Kiruri Jul 14, 2020

Please check what an organisation called Mawingu are doing in Kenya with the white space frequencies, it could provide insights

Nathi Mbele Jul 28, 2020

I know Mawingu very well. I met then in Kenya a couple years ago but Kenyan regulators have not yet commenced with commercial TVWS

Thomas Mueller Jul 16, 2020

Interesting Idea but with regards to the frequency used , those are licensed and regulated bands. How do you achieve to be able to use those frequencies? Furthermore that would be a proprietary technology which could probably be used in a P2P model but what about a P2N model as it probably would need proprietary CPEs?

Nathi Mbele Aug 9, 2020

Television White Spaces (TVWS) is the term used to describe portions of unused radio spectrum; the gaps left between bands allocated for TV broadcasting in the Ultra High Frequency (UHF) range (470 MHz to 694 MHz), excluding the Radio Astronomy sub-band 606 MHz – 614 MHz. The Independent Communications Regulatory Authority of South Africa (ICASA), as the national regulator mandated to manage spectrum resources, enforce compliance to regulations and monitor quality of service of telecommunication networks, published “Regulations on the use of Television White Spaces” in 2018. Our operations are made possible by these regulations. The ICASA TVWS Regulation is a three-tiered ecosystem that is composed of two types of
geo-location spectrum databases (GLSDs) namely; the Reference Geolocation Spectrum Database (R-GLSD) and the Secondary Geo-location Spectrum Database (S-GLSD) positioned in the first and second tiers respectively, and TVWS networks positioned in the third tier. Reference Geo-location Spectrum Database (R-GLSD) is a GLSD operated by ICASA to perform baseline calculations for the countrywide TVWS availability maps for setting regulatory limits. R-GLSD is primarily used by ICASA to monitor activities of S-GLSD providers (at the moment on CSIR is assisting with S-GLSD for free of charge) and enforce compliance to the Regulations. CSIR's S-GLSD provides available TVWS channels to radio equipment without causing harmful interference to the incumbent users of the band, in line with Regulation 5 of the ICASA TVWS Regulations. CSIR has developed the S-GLSD platform in compliance with the ICASA TVWS Regulations. We have a solid TVWS Regulatory Framework in South Africa for TVWS deployment.

Thomas Mueller Aug 9, 2020

Dear Nathi,

Thank you very much. This detailed response is very much appreciated.

Nathi Mbele Aug 9, 2020

Hi Thomas. I will published final submission sometimes next week better addressing most questions and integrating inputs from you and other participates on this exciting co-creation journey :)

Rahim Iqbal Jul 17, 2020

Hi Nathi, I hope you are fine.

I read through your proposal and comments, You have covered most of the points exquisitely. I would like to make some recommendations as you go for your final submission.

1) Explain the technology you are using, and compare its cost with that of cellular internet and broadband.
2) The role TV stations will be playing, directly or indirectly, and if there is a cost in including them.
3) Do explain how you are getting access to these unused frequencies, as in via any government or local security department.
4) In your story include your personal experience, challenges you faced, and how you overcame them.
5) Refer to the given canvases before submitting your final proposal it will help.

All and all a great idea, keep up the hard work and let me know if I can be of any help. Thank you.

Nathi Mbele Jul 28, 2020

Thank you for such a comprehesive feedback I am working on adjusting the idea based on your input. Much appreciated

Users tagged:

Victoria Masso Jul 21, 2020

Status label added: Mentor feedback received

Nathi Mbele Jul 28, 2020

Exciting news

Users tagged:

James Kiruri Jul 22, 2020

Hello Nathi, kindly review my idea Teleeza and share any improvement thoughts so that it can progress to the next stage

Nathi Mbele Jul 28, 2020

Hello James. Great idea I've reviewed your idea all the best.

Users tagged:

DJ Koeman Jul 30, 2020

Hey, nice one! Couple of questions. How do you intend to tackle different regulatory environments across SSA? Here in Kenya TVWS spectrum and sub-licensing had been allocated to the TV stations. Only recently, driven by COVID, they start looking at it making it commercially available. Secondly, if you go to rural, disposable income is low(er) usually, whereas the price for TVWS CPE is high(er). How do you overcome that hurdle? As a result of the latter, TVWS is still mostly used as middle mile technology. I appreciate your thoughts on this

Nathi Mbele Aug 9, 2020

The South African regulatory environment on TV White Space is far ahead compare with Kenyan environment. I have been to Kenya twice as Kenya was my preferred country to launch TVWS. However, South African regulator is +/- 6 month from full commercially launch. A couple of successful trials started back in 2013 and in April this year we started a TVWS deployment also driven by Covid 19 TVWS emergency spectrum allocation. Last month one OEM received a full type approval. This was achieved by this OEM firstly being a CE certified for hardware and subsequently passing the rigorous testing with the CSIR Secondary Geo Location Spectrum Database (SGLSD). The SGLSD is used for free under Covid 19 emergency spectrum so there's a fully functioning local developed SGLSD. Having this first full Type Approval certification of TVWS devices to be issued by local regulator in compliance with the South African TVWS Regulations of 2018 is amazing. We are using TVWS as a middle mile for hotspots in the rural areas but rural based businesses like farms and public sector facilities like schools and health centres the TVWS is used as the last mile. At the moment of course CPE prices are still high but as supply increases when more OEMs pass compliance requirements we expect prices to drop.

Users tagged:

DJ Koeman Aug 10, 2020

Thanks for the response, 100% in line with my thinking around this! I will be following your progress with great interest

Davidson Akujiofor Aug 18, 2020

Great work!

Nivashini Rave Rattey Aug 31, 2020

Describe the mechanisms, process and key activities behind your MVP and clearly state how these will address the needs of your target audience. Also, clearly state what kind of impact will your solution have on your community.

Users tagged:

Nathi Mbele Aug 31, 2020

Thank you for such feedback. I have done my best to describe the mechanisms, process and key activities behind our MVP. The impact is covered by our story (our narrative) session.

Users tagged:

Nivashini Rave Rattey Aug 31, 2020

Status label added: Expert feedback received

Nathi Mbele Aug 31, 2020

Hello Nivashini. Since I have received expert feedback, how can I fill the final submission form? During the webinar the other day, I overhead a 2 - 3 min video submission. Is this compulsory and where can I find guidelines so I can do the video today.

Users tagged:

Nivashini Rave Rattey Sep 1, 2020

Status label added: Submission completed

Nivashini Rave Rattey Sep 8, 2020

Status label added: Idea under jury review

Nivashini Rave Rattey Sep 8, 2020

The idea has been progressed to the next milestone.